Anyone travelling in the Arctic or climbing in the high mountains faces a dilemma. On the one hand, staying properly hydrated is essential for survival, and the only available source of water is snow melted on a camping stove. On the other hand, cooking outdoors in severe cold and strong winds consumes enormous amounts of valuable fuel. The natural instinct, therefore, is to take shelter in a tent or snow cave and light the stove inside. Although this may seem like a comfortable solution, it carries a potentially fatal risk: poisoning from invisible carbon monoxide. Understanding this danger is essential for winter survival.
What Is Carbon Monoxide (CO)?
Carbon monoxide, also known as CO, is a product of incomplete combustion. Under ideal conditions, with an adequate supply of oxygen, gas or petrol burns completely, producing carbon dioxide (CO2) and water (H2O). However, such ideal combustion conditions are rare, if they occur at all. When the oxygen supply is limited, carbon monoxide (CO) is also produced during combustion. In winter conditions, when a shelter is small and poorly ventilated, its concentration can rapidly rise to dangerous levels.
Carbon monoxide is a colourless and odourless gas. These very characteristics make it so dangerous, as we cannot detect it with our senses. You will neither smell anything unusual nor see any smoke that might warn you of its presence.
How Does Carbon Monoxide Affect the Human Body?
Carbon monoxide literally “blocks” your blood. CO molecules have a much greater affinity for haemoglobin (the protein in red blood cells responsible for transporting oxygen) than oxygen itself. When you inhale carbon monoxide, it begins to take the place of oxygen in your bloodstream, forming a compound called carboxyhaemoglobin. Unfortunately, this compound is very stable, meaning that once haemoglobin binds with carbon monoxide, it can no longer perform its normal function of transporting oxygen. The more haemoglobin bound to carbon monoxide, the less oxygen your blood can carry. This leads to a gradual lack of oxygen in all tissues and organs, including the brain and heart. Your body begins to suffocate from within.
What Are the Symptoms of Carbon Monoxide Poisoning?
It is essential to recognise the symptoms of carbon monoxide poisoning and respond immediately.
- Early symptoms:
- Headache is one of the earliest and most common warning signs.
- More serious symptoms:
- Dizziness
- Nausea
- Vomiting
- Life-threatening symptoms:
- Loss of consciousness
- Coma, which can lead to death
Remember that in mountainous environments or during strenuous physical activity, these early symptoms — headaches and nausea — can easily be mistaken for fatigue or altitude sickness. This makes the danger even more insidious.
How Can a Camping Stove Become a Source of Carbon Monoxide?
The combustion of fuel in a camping stove can be either safe (complete combustion) or dangerous (incomplete combustion). Incomplete combustion produces large amounts of carbon monoxide. You can, however, assess the combustion process by carefully observing the flame. The colour of the flame is the most important indicator of combustion quality.
| What to look for: | ✅ Safe Combustion | ❌ Dangerous Combustion |
| Flame colour | Uniform blue | Red, yellow or orange |
| Bottom of the cooking pot | Clean burner and cookware | Visible soot deposits on the pot and burner |
Fuel Type and Stove Model
Research shows that all types of camping fuel — propane/isobutane gas canisters, white gas (camping petrol) and kerosene — can produce dangerous concentrations of CO in poorly ventilated spaces. Liquid fuels generally produce more carbon monoxide. However, the relationship is not quite that simple! Different stove models can produce different amounts of carbon monoxide even when burning the same fuel. Fuel type alone is not enough to determine how safe a stove is.
Carbon Monoxide in a Tent or Snow Cave: Two Critical Moments
Field research has identified two stages of the cooking process that produce the largest spikes in carbon monoxide concentration:
- Priming: This brief process, lasting just 1–2 minutes, involves preheating the burner and produces the highest instantaneous concentrations of carbon monoxide during the entire cooking cycle. Be especially alert at this stage.
- Placing the pot on the flame: When a cold cooking pot comes into contact with the flame, it disperses and cools the flame. As other studies have shown, this seemingly harmless action can increase carbon monoxide production by as much as tenfold.
Condition of the Burner
Studies have also demonstrated that the technical condition of the burner is critically important. Lighting a burner covered in soot resulted in carbon monoxide levels increasing by as much as tenfold. Incomplete combustion caused by dirty or clogged burner jets is a major reason for a sudden increase in carbon monoxide emissions.
In a study conducted in north-eastern Greenland, researchers measured carbon monoxide levels while cooking in five different snow caves. They used an MSR WhisperLite liquid-fuel stove, priming it with ethanol before melting snow using white gas. I have used exactly the same system in the Arctic, for example, on Spitsbergen and during my Greenland traverse. There is just one difference: I use an MSR XGK stove.
What were the findings?
The authors concluded that although a single cooking session lasting less than 10 minutes may remain within safe limits, the stove priming process itself generates dangerously high short-term carbon monoxide exposure. They also confirmed that the condition of the burner is critically important. A dirty stove can emit up to ten times more toxic CO than a clean one.

Cooking Pot Diameter and Carbon Monoxide Emissions
The choice of cookware can have a measurable effect on the amount of carbon monoxide produced. A larger pot diameter causes the flame to spread out, which in turn can lead to incomplete combustion. In a 2024 study, researchers compared a Coleman Dual Fuel 533 petrol stove using two pots: one with a base diameter of 16.5 cm and the other measuring 22 cm. The study, conducted under controlled laboratory conditions, confirmed that the larger pot produced higher carbon monoxide emissions.
Carbon Monoxide in a Tent or Snow Cave: Ventilation Is Essential
In a study conducted in Greenland, researchers excavated five snow caves. They were built in a similar way, and each was equipped with ventilation openings with a cross-sectional area of 63 cm². This is equivalent to a circular opening approximately 9 cm in diameter — about the size of an average ski pole basket. Previous studies had considered openings of this size sufficient to keep CO concentrations below the safe threshold of 35 ppm (parts per million). However, in this experiment, this threshold was exceeded in 10 out of 16 trials. This demonstrates that even apparently adequate ventilation does not guarantee complete safety. Even if you build a snow cave correctly and provide ventilation, you cannot rely on ventilation alone.
In short, cutting a ventilation hole in the roof does not mean you can safely doze off while waiting for your water to boil. Constant vigilance is essential.
Exposure Time
The risk of poisoning depends on both the concentration of carbon monoxide and the duration of exposure.
One experiment involved short cooking sessions (15–21 minutes) in a snow cave. The study showed that individual, short cooking sessions (lasting less than 10 minutes) may be tolerated in well-constructed snow shelters.
Another study involved a two-hour exposure inside a tent. Using a kerosene stove, researchers recorded elevated levels of carbon monoxide-bound haemoglobin in the blood of all study participants. These elevated levels were accompanied by a decrease in blood oxygen saturation (from an average of 98% to 95%) and an increase in heart rate. This indicates that the body was attempting to deliver oxygen to its tissues despite the developing oxygen deprivation.
The conclusion? The risk of severe poisoning increases dramatically as the operating time of a stove in an enclosed, poorly ventilated space becomes longer.

The Effect of Altitude
Climbing at high altitudes introduces additional risks. A study conducted at an altitude of 3,200 m above sea level demonstrated that even a single, brief exposure to CO while cooking inside a snow shelter increased carbon monoxide concentrations both in the air and in the blood of participants. Although no significant changes in vital signs or symptoms were observed, it is important to remember that even low levels of carbon monoxide can aggravate the symptoms of altitude sickness.
Now let’s turn these findings into simple, practical rules that could save your life.
Rules for Safe Cooking Inside a Shelter
Remember these eight rules whenever you consider cooking inside an enclosed shelter:
- Cook outdoors whenever possible. This is always the safest option. Cooking indoors should be a last resort.
- Ensure maximum ventilation. If you must cook inside, open the entrance to your snow cave, tent or igloo as wide as possible, and also open the ventilation opening at the highest point of the shelter. Opening the entrance near ground level and a ventilation opening in the roof is the most effective way to remove accumulating carbon monoxide.
- Keep your equipment clean. Regularly clean your stove and burner jet. Watch for soot accumulating on your cookware, as this is a sign of incomplete combustion. Using a dirty, soot-covered and poorly maintained burner has been shown to cause an increase of up to tenfold in average carbon monoxide concentrations.
- Take particular care during priming. The priming phase generates high short-term concentrations of carbon monoxide. Whenever possible, carry out this process in a better-ventilated area.
- Watch the flame. It is your best early-warning system. If the flame changes from a uniform blue to yellow or orange, treat this as an alarm signal. Stop cooking immediately, turn off the stove and ventilate the shelter thoroughly.
- Never use your stove for heating. Its only purpose is cooking. Using it as a heater is asking for trouble, as it prolongs its operation to dangerous levels and produces CO without active supervision.
- Choose cookware with a smaller diameter. This allows the flame to remain more concentrated and efficient, reducing the risk of incomplete combustion.
- Keep cooking time to a minimum. Reduce cooking time as much as possible. Avoid spending extended periods in an enclosed space while the stove is running. Prolonged exposure presents the greatest risk.
Conclusion: Your Safety Depends on Your Knowledge
Carbon monoxide in a tent or snow cave is a real and potentially fatal danger. This is not, however, a reason to panic, but rather a reason to develop good habits. You need to be aware of the risks. You need to maintain your equipment. And, finally, you must follow safety rules without exception to minimise the danger. With this knowledge, you can make informed decisions that will help keep you safe when camping in winter, in the Arctic or at high altitude.
References:
1. Nielsen SU, Karlsen A. “A Field Study of Carbon Monoxide Levels in Snow Caves During Short-Term Stove Use”. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. June 2024; 35(2): 129–137. doi: 10.1177/10806032241230241
2. Thurman JT, Leavitt R, Buchanan JT, Shreffler J, Huecker MR, Early T. “Carbon Monoxide Levels Produced by Propane/Isobutane Canister Stoves inside a Tent”. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. December 2023; 34(4): 513–516. doi: 10.1016/j.wem.2023.06.006
3. Keyes LE, Hamilton RS, Rose JS. “Carbon monoxide exposure from cooking in snow caves at high altitude”. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. Autumn 2001; 12(3): 208–212. doi: 10.1580/1080-6032(2001)012[0208:cmefci]2.0.co;2
4. Thomassen Ø, Brattebø G, Rostrup M. “Carbon monoxide poisoning while using a small cooking stove in a tent”. American Journal of Emergency Medicine. May 2004; 22(3): 204–206. doi: 10.1016/j.ajem.2004.02.011
5. Leigh-Smith S, Watt I, McFadyen A, Grant S. “Comparison of carbon monoxide levels during heating of ice and water to boiling point with a camping stove”. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. Autumn 2004; 15(3): 164–170. doi: 10.1580/1080-6032(2004)15[164:cocmld]2.0.co;2
6. Leigh-Smith S, Stevenson R, Watt M, Watt I, McFadyen A, Grant S. “Does pan diameter influence carbon monoxide levels during heating of water to boiling point with a camping stove?”. Wilderness & Environmental Medicine. Autumn 2004; 15(3): 171–174. doi: 10.1580/1080-6032(2004)15[171:dpdicm]2.0.co;2


